The Drowned

[Amazon Link]
(paid link)

I put this book on my get-at-library list thanks to its inclusion on the WSJ's 2024 list of Best Mysteries.

It's #4 in a series set in 1950s Ireland, involving detective St. John Strafford and Quirke, a pathologist employed to autopsy suspicious corpses. Consumer note: without spoiling things too much, you might want to read the preceding books first. I had read only number three, The Lock-Up; my report is here. My takeaway there: not my cup of tea. I think I should have been warned.

But anyway: The book opens when a lonely guy living in a trailer comes across an apparently abandoned car in the middle of a field. (It turns out he's lonely for a very good reason.) The owner shows up, claiming that his wife has wandered off, and he suspects she might have done herself in, throwing herself into the storm-tossed nearby sea. They go to the closest farmhouse to call in the disappearance, where there's a strange interaction between the husband, the farmer, and the farmer's wife. Leaving the lonely guy puzzled, but he has secrets of his own…

Everybody's pretty glum here, battling all sorts of dysfunction: physical, mental, romantic, professional. And that's where the melancholy narrative dwells, endlessly, with only occasional nods to the disappearance. Eventually, there's another disappearance, with a relatively quick discovery of a perhaps-crime. But is it? Our lonely guy turns out to be an obvious suspect.

Again: not my cuppa. The characters have their problems, but they weren't sympathetic enough for me to be interested. The book would have been a lot shorter if they had just concentrated on discovering what happened to the wife.