Mr. Ramirez goes in a different, but equally valid, direction:
And, in words, Jeffrey Blehar finds the "deal" to be Futile But Revealing.
Why would the president of the United States suddenly throw a sagging Russia this no-strings-attached lifeline, allowing it to infuse its war machine with billions of dollars funded directly by its strategic enemy? Well, you don’t really need to guess: Trump is nothing if not obvious, and he wants to make sure America’s “Great Farmers, Ranchers, and Truckers” know he’s willing to cut a deal with the devil and stab our allies in the back for immediate access to a pathetic fraction of U.S. demand for diesel. (The U.S. consumes roughly 3 million barrels, or 402,000 metric tons, per day.)
But also, on a more important (but unspoken) level, asking Russia to sell us diesel in direct contravention of America’s larger interests is the tacit admission of a larger truth: We seemingly have no plan on how to extricate ourselves from the Iran war and its attendant oil shock, so it’s time to go begging to our enemies. This won’t affect the price of diesel at the pump save at the barest margins, and not in time for Election Day. But it’s a headline! And Trump loves headlines, at least the ones he consciously generates.
Finally, the fact that Trump — in his political extremity — saw fit to turn to Russia also reaffirms a far smaller, and uglier, truth about him: He just likes Russia and Putin on a gut level, in a way he will never feel about our actual allies. As unthinkable as it would be for literally any other American president to suddenly inject a shot of life into the Russian war machine — remember, we currently claim to be seeking an end to the Russo-Ukrainian war, yet this would only prolong it — it makes all the sense for Trump to be indifferent to such considerations.
Trump has never been terribly psychologically complex: In his Cold War–shaped mind, Russia is forever coded as “strong,” our historic geopolitical foe deserving of respect — and maybe a little understanding as well. Meanwhile, Ukraine is coded in his mind with weakness, Biden Democrats, and Volodymyr Zelensky, the man who in Donald Trump’s mind will forever be synonymous with his first impeachment.
We had a chance to avoid this with Nikki Haley. If only…
Also of note:
-
Bad news for geoengineers. Ars Technica brings us the post mortem: They war-gamed dimming the Sun. It went even worse than you think.
When it comes to deciding the fate of the planet, Colleen Golja always thought science and reason would have a seat at the table. That was until one morning last September in London, when the climate researcher took part in the first in a series of war games. The goal: to prevent an uncontrolled global race to develop a technology aimed at cooling the planet but that comes with vast, unknown risks that could reshape life on Earth.
“I thought that would be such an easy thing. Like, we can all agree to do ethical research and make sure it’s for the better of all humans,” she told WIRED. “And boy, was I wrong.”
The simulation, titled Exploring Geopolitical Tipping Points and Climate Cooling Strategies, saw a couple dozen foreign-relations experts, scientists, military personnel, and former government officials from across the world convene in a meeting room at Queen Mary University of London. After making introductions over coffee and little yogurts, they sat at tables arranged in a square with the name of the country or organization each person was playing: national governments, climate NGOs and nonprofits, indigenous groups, and tech companies. Golja was assigned to provide technical advice to help participants make scientifically literate decisions.
Caveat Lector: This article "originally appeared at wired.com", a longtime foe of anything that doesn't involve AOC-Approved Green New Deal climate policies.
But it fits in well with something Pun Salad said over twenty years ago (and many times since then):
There's a sense in which technological solutions to global warming are even scarier than global warming itself. You think you have conflicts setting the thermostat in your house, with Pa wanting to save energy and Ma wanting it warmer, and the kids complaining no matter what? Multiply that kerfuffle by a few billion, erase the familial love, and give everyone armed forces. Uh oh.
But if geoengineering our way out of global warming seems difficult, it's even less likely that we'll do it via legislation and the heavy hand of regulation. I know where I'd be putting my money.
It's difficult for True Believers to imagine that their schemes aren't immune from exactly the same problems they note in the proposals of others.
-
It's just down the path from the Meadow of Mendacity. Dan Greenberg at Cato updates Lewis Carroll with J. D. Vance's Walk in the Forest of Forgetfulness. (The Forest is an area of Neverland where all who enter forget the names of things.)
In a press conference last week, our vice president displayed such forgetfulness. In J.D. Vance’s discussion of new restrictions on H‑1B eligibility, he was asked what he understood “socialism” to be. He responded:
“It’s honestly a hard term to define these days. Classically, you would think socialism is about prioritizing workers. And yet in reality, most of the self-described socialists running across the United States of America are going to howl about this announcement today, which is prioritizing American workers over foreign workers. So I don’t know what the term means anymore. I think in reality, what it actually means in the American context is that you want to replace American workers with foreign workers, and you want boys to play in girls’ sports. That’s what united the socialists that I see running across the United States of America today.”
Vance was playing at forgetfulness here: Of course, socialism has little or nothing to do with immigration or gender. But many of us have not forgotten what socialism is: those who want to know “what it actually means in the American context” could look at “Workers Deserve More!” a recent platform statement of the Democratic Socialists of America (DSA) — or at my colleague Alex Nowrasteh’s recent analysis of it.
More broadly, many of the DSA’s recommendations target political and legal institutions that are central to a free society — the ability to offer, bargain about, and make agreements concerning prices; the right to petition the government; the institution of private property; and a government composed of competing branches and separated powers — for elimination. The DSA platform treats them as hindrances, but these institutions serve as political solutions to basic problems of political life.
And then they cried "Off with their heads!"
-
Good news and … not so good news. John H. Cochrane brings us Part 2 of his Affordability Trilogy.
Affordability? It does seem a bit petulant. American’s standard of living is greater than any large country, and better than ever in the past. We earn on average 40% more than Europeans, British, Japanese, and Canadians. Poverty just hit an all time low. Health indicators hit an all time high. Inequality is falling. Some things have gotten more expensive, but other things are cheaper. Real wages are rising. Is a new multi-bedroom house in a nice suburb of a hot city expensive? Yes. But ask Europeans, who live in tiny apartments. What is everyone complaining about?
Well, the level of prices, as measured by the consumer price index, is 27 percent higher than it was just before inflation hit in January 2021, and 14% higher than it would have been had inflation been 2% that whole time. Though average real wages largely kept up with inflation, that’s not true for everyone. Many people who got new jobs got raises. But many people in old jobs did not. People on fixed nominal incomes or who want to buy houses or stocks are worse off. Inflation creates a lot of churn: some gain, some lose. Anyone who held government bonds lost about 14% due to inflation, and more as long-term bond prices fell.
People hate inflation. People hate higher prices. You can lecture them all you want about real wages, about “transitory,” but people hate higher prices. That ought to be an important lesson.
John makes an interesting point about the Federal Reserve that I didn't fully appreciate before:
Congress gave the Federal Reserve a “price stability” mandate. The Fed interpreted that mandate to mean 2% inflation forever. Prices should double every 35 years. And even that 2% is only a forward-looking aspiration. The Fed lets bygones be bygones. If inflation hits 10%, as it did in 2022, the Fed does not try to run inflation lower than 2% for a while, or even slight deflation, so that inflation will average 2% over time. The Fed does not even think of trying to bring the level of prices back to where they were. Even so-called transitory inflation means permanently higher prices.
That certainly makes their job easier. And it makes me more sympathetic to the dangerous libertarian wackos who cry "End the Fed". Maybe they have a point.
-
Oh, good. We found something on TV to be outraged about. At Reason, Robby Soave thinks The Shane Gillis SNL backlash is really stupid. To get you up to speed, if necessary:
Shane Gillis is an actor and comedian. He first came to my attention in September 2019, when he was hired to be a new cast member on Saturday Night Live—and then abruptly fired after it was revealed that he had (gasp) told offensive jokes. (SNL creator Lorne Michaels subsequently said that the network forced him to fire Gillis, and he thought the whole controversy was stupid.)
Since then, Gillis's career has really taken off, to the extent that he has repeatedly returned to SNL as a guest host. He did so again on October 10, delivering a monologue in which he made the following observation: "I haven't been to the gym in so long, I didn't know women just dress like whores now."
Confession: I'm easily amused, so I watch SNL every week there's a new episode. And c'mon who could not avoid laughing at…
"… and I paid with a check." I've seen that maybe a dozen times, and it still makes me laugh.
| Recently on the book blog: |

![[Pun Salad Movie Poster]](/ps/images/ps_movie_poster.png)


