… laid out for all to see:
David Brooks, the one and only Granite Geek, gloats:
"Global-warming skeptic turns into a convert". He's referring
to Bjørn Lomborg, author of The
Yet Lomborg's new position is not much of "U-turn," striking or otherwise. Lomborg has acknowledged the reality of human-induced warming in all of his books, while discounting some of the more apocalyptic scenarios. In his 2007 book Cool It: The Skeptical Environmentalist's Guide to Global Warming (which I reviewed here), he declared that climate change was a "problem" and recommended a strikingly similar response. Specifically, he called for the imposition of a carbon tax and urged a global commitment to financing climate-friendly R&D to the tune of $25 billion per year. His new proposal is more ambitious - a larger tax to fund even more research - but otherwise is much the same. So, too, is his overall message: Climate change is one of many problems the world faces, must compete with other priorities, and should be addressed in a cost-effective manner. Perhaps what's really changed is not Lomborg's perspective, but the degree to which commentators actually pay attention to what he writes.David Brooks is kind of the science guy at the Nashua Telegraph, but it seems that Adler's implied criticism applies: he pays a lot more attention to what Lomborg's adversaries allege about him than what Lomborg is actually saying.
Here's a question that got my attention: "Did
Bill Gates waste a billion dollars because he failed to understand the
formula for the standard deviation of the mean?" (Answer: yeah,
probably. Good stuff at the link.)
Gosh, Walter Russell Mead has some good advice
for students in this Back To School season. It's practically
unexcerptable, but do check it out.
The trick is to get it to a student who (a) is not too young to benefit from Mead's advice; (b) is not too old to benefit from Mead's advice; and (c) is not a pigheaded know-it-all psychologically unable to take Mead's advice. Good luck on that.
My advice to students: pay real close attention to that whole "standard deviation" thing.