How Cold Will It Have to Get in Hell…

[Amazon Link]
(paid link)

… before more people will start recognizing this simple truth, as described by Jeff Jacoby: The swastika stands for evil and mass murder. So does the hammer and sickle. He notes the recent confluence of (1) the 100th anniversary of Lenin's death; and (2) International Holocaust Remembrance Day. I'd also guess he noticed the recent publicity about a few Nazi-related sites on Substack.

The communist system introduced by Lenin has led to more slaughter and suffering than any other movement in history. For sheer murderous horror, there has never been a force to compare to it. The Nazis didn't come close. Adolf Hitler's regime eradicated 6 million Jews in the unprecedented genocide of the Holocaust. The Germans also killed at least 5 million non-Jews, among them ethnic Poles, prisoners of war, Romani people, and the disabled.

But the Nazi toll adds up to barely a tenth of the lives that have been extinguished by communist dictatorships. According to The Black Book of Communism, a magisterial compendium of communist crimes first published in France in 1997, the fanaticism unleashed by Lenin's revolution has sent at least 100 million men, women, and children to early graves. Beginning in 1917, communist regimes on four continents — from Russia and Eastern Europe to China and North Korea to Cuba and Ethiopia — engineered death on a scale unmatched in human annals.

Yet communism rarely evokes the instinctive loathing that Nazism does. To this day there are those who still insist that communism is admirable and wholesome, or that it has never been properly implemented, or that with all its failings it is better than capitalism. Many people who would find it unthinkable to deck themselves in Nazi regalia — when Britain's Prince Harry wore a swastika armband to a costume party in 2005, a major scandal ensued — view communist-themed fashion as trendy or kitschy.

Jacoby notes five possible explanations for this odd behavior. But mass-murdering ideology is a mass-murdering ideology, no? So (as Jacoby notes) those explanations are not justifications.

Recently on the book blog:

A Prayer for Owen Meany

(paid link)

Another book down on my reading project of reading all the previously-unread entries on the New York Times 2021 list of the best books of the past 125 years. This leaves me with only two left to go! I don't know if this John Irving tome (640 pages) would be on my list of best books, but I liked it OK.

As a personal bonus, it is mostly set in my corner of New Hampshire, with references to local towns: Durham, Newmarket, Hampton Beach, … with a fictionalized version of Exeter, which Irving dubs "Gravesend". The book's narrator is John Wheelwright. The book's first sentence:

I am doomed to remember a boy with a wrecked voice—not because of his voice, or because he was the smallest person I ever knew, or even because he was the instrument of my mother's death, but because he is the reason I believe in God; I am a Christian because of Owen Meany.

That's a pretty good grabber.

John relates his life, and Owen's, from a 1987 vantage point, starting with their childhood in Gravesend. Irving emphasizes Owen's "wrecked voice" putting his dialog in ALL CAPS. (Including his writing.) In 640 pages, there's a lot of room for a lot of stories about their activities, their families, their friends and enemies. And how John's mother died. But it mainly centers around Owen's certainty about his eventual destiny. And Irving doesn't get to revealing that until the very end.

Those stories are full of wry observations, humor, pathos, and (sorry) occasional death. (It kind of reminded me of Garrison Keillor's Lake Wobegon yarns, except for more death.) One amusing bit describes a wealthy town couple devoted to the idea of (what we now call) gender fluidity. In a nice touch, the wife is on the town library board and is an ardent book-banner—of any title she thinks might be advocating sexual stereotyping. Things change.

One minor irritation was John's occasional rants about 1987-current events. He despises Ronald Reagan, bemoans the Iran-Contra scandal. For this 2024 reader, that's more than slightly distracting. (That reminded me of Isaac Asimov's speculation in Robots and Empire that the 1979 Three Mile Island accident would have a major impact on future events.) There's also quite a bit about Vietnam, but that's at least relevant to Owen's story. However, it's clear that John has been deeply affected by Owen's life, and more than slightly damaged.


Last Modified 2024-01-29 11:59 AM EDT